One of the phenomena sheet metal fabricators must contend when bending parts is something called bending allowance. The reason for this is that when metal is bent, the material on the inside of the bend compresses, while the material on the outside stretches, and not by equal amounts (for reasons that get too technical even for this article). The result is that the workpiece actually “grows” in overall size if not compensated for. This compensation can be calculated using something called the K-factor, which considers variables such as the type of material, its thickness, the inside radius of the bend, and how it is bent.
What does this mean to the part designer? Even if your part is designed as a sheet metal part in a CAD Solids Modeler, when flattened, the flat development may or may not be correct, depending on the above-noted variables. It is for this reason that reputable metal fabricators may revise the model, and add their particular press brake bending parameters to create an updated flat development that will yield the part you require, and within your required tolerances.
Knowing your fabricator’s process and press brake tooling available (notably the radius of the male break dies), goes a long way to save time and potential surprises. The purpose of this article is to demonstrate to engineers and designers the technical aspects of how we (and you!) can determine the K-factor in sheet metal design.
When files are provided by the customer, the 3D model has no bending parameters specified if it’s a STEP, IGES, or Parasolid file, and bending parameters are set to a default value in SolidWorks. When the flat pattern is developed for the part to be cut, it will often have incorrect dimensions to yield the customer’s desired bent part. In order to overcome this problem, your sheet metal fabricator should calculate the K-factor and revise the part’s flat development to yield your desired part within your specified tolerances.
Why is K-factor important in sheet metal manufacturing?
The K-factor in sheet metal design is important since it is used to correctly calculate flat patterns. This is because it is directly related to how much material is stretched during bending. K-factor is the ratio of the neutral axis to the material thickness. K-factor plays a key role in understanding the limits a material can handle during sheet metal bending.
General equation for K-factor:
BA= Bend Allowance
μ= Material Thickness
ρ = Inside Radius
β = Bend Angle (in degrees)
The general equation for K-factor is used to make sure the K-factor used in SolidWorks is reliable to manufacture parts with the right dimensions and to see if it applies to the manufacturing process (bending in a press brake die). Follow the formula and calculations that follow, or click here to access one of the many online K-Factor calculators.
1. Measurements taken from a bracket we manufacture:
β = 90°
ρ = 0.142 in (see Fig. 1)
μ = 0.135 in (Hot Rolled Steel)
FL1 = 1.378 in (see Fig. 2)
FL2 = 1.462 in (see Fig. 3)
Initial length = 2.583 in (see Fig. 5)
2. Now that you have your measurements, we’ll determine the BA. To do this, first determine to bend outside set back (OSSB)
OSSB=Tan (β/2)(ρ+μ) Tan (90/2)(0.142+0.135)
OSSB = .277 in
Then determine the bend deduction (BD is not part of the formula but can be used instead of the K factor if desired).
BD = FL1 + FL2 – Initial length
3. Calculate bend allowance using the following equation
BA = 2*OSSB
= 2* 0.277
= 0.297 in
4. Plug the Bend allowance (BA), the Bend Angle (β), Inside Radius (ρ), and Material Thickness (μ) into the below equation to determine the K-factor (K).
We usually set a default K-factor value of 0.33 when designing sheet metal models in SolidWorks. But that can cause problems when customers supply 3D CAD files that have used default or unknown K-factor, with the result being that the bent part dimensions or tolerances become unachievable. In that case, your metal fabricator must perform a trial-and-error approach to determine the right K-factor, where they adjust the K-factor in SolidWorks until the desired dimensions are achieved. Therefore, the above equations are used as a practical method to calculate the K-factor so it cuts down the number of trials needed in the error trial-and-error approach to calculate the K-factor in SolidWorks.
A practical method to calculate the K-factor
1. PREPARE SAMPLES
- Begin by preparing 5 sample blanks which are of equal and known sizes .
- Record material type and thickness in test report
- The blanks should be at least a foot long to ensure an even bend, and a few inches deep to make sure you can sit them against the back stops.
- Measure Initial length of metal blank
2. BEND TESTING
- Set up the press brake with the desired tooling you’ll be using to fabricate this metal thickness. Make sure to use the same die and punch for all samples. If different punch or die is used it needs to be mentioned in the test report.
- Place a 90° bend in the center of the piece.
3. MEASURE SAMPLES
- Measure the flange length and inside radius of each piece, record length A,B and radius R as shown in the Fig. 6.
- The test report should have material type, material thickness, initial blank length, inside radius, flange length A and B at this step.
- Calculate the K-factor by following the procedure mentioned earlier with the measurements obtained.
- This K-factor value is to be used in the trail-and-error approach in the following steps.
- Use the flange lengths measured to create a model on SolidWorks as shown in Fig. 7 and set the K-factor value obtained from the calculation (Step 4) in the SolidWorks model.